team
February 26, 2024
5 Minute Read 520 views
A different recognized sad girl narrative originates from a few visual narratives we underneath the username (menhera girl). Since the 2013 Momose keeps tweeted you to example twenty four hours, offering an excellent mouthless girl from inside the a beneficial sailor suit (college consistent). In place of Kotoha (2012) manga that is drawn in an anime format, Momose’s job is an individual committee comical that depicts an excellent girl suffering loneliness, sadness, and you may anxiety. Very photos try associated with several verbal lines of your own menhera girl’s monolog otherwise an initial dialogue anywhere between their particular and you will anonymous other people who seemingly don’t understand precisely what the girl is struggling having. Although it is not demonstrated whether or not the menhera girl have an excellent diagnosable rational disorder otherwise what causes their unique angst, self-injury (hand reducing) is actually represented as a way for the newest menhera girl to manage with internal discomfort or even perform an excellent dissociative impact and make yes she is however alive (Contour step one). At the time of , Momose’s Twitter account features more than 85,000 followers and the line of their own design is actually typed in a text entitled “The Sound away from a gray Girl” (Momose, 2016).
Shape step 1. “Doesn’t arm-reducing damage?” “It does not hurt (around my personal cardiovascular system).” A graphic narrative i (). Picture reproduced with consent regarding the writer.
These unfortunate girl narratives signify the jargon given the newest creators which have a comparatively natural and all sorts of-related title in order to portray contemporary Japanese girls experiencing the pain regarding way of life. It will probably be worth appeal your unfortunate girl menhera symbolizes stereotypical Japanese femininity, like submissiveness, self-manage, and you can clear of selfishness. Momose (2016) mouthless reputation eloquently shows that the fresh menhera girl suffers alone; everything we get a hold of and you will learn about their particular is by using their internal monolog filled with anxiety and you will worry, but she’s got no voice to improve. Self-injury is actually portrayed as an easy way so you can externalize and you can deal with their unique internal pain, rather than connecting their particular anxiety to help you other people. Momose’s depiction of menhera girl given that a good “grey girl” is particularly advising in this regard. In her own study from news portrayals off food problems and you may mind-harm among Japanese women, Hansen (2011) claims that women in contemporary Japan often face “the new paradox out-of navigating contradictive femininity in the a grey area between the normal in addition to disordered” (p. 57). As “the favorable and you can brush girl” demands Japanese female to work out rigorous thinking-control over their bodies so you’re able to “prevents the brand new worst” on their own (Hansen, 2011, p. 61). On unfortunate girl narratives, self-hurting steps like mind-created regurgitation, deprivation, and you can self-cutting was represented because the an effective borderline disordered act did by more youthful feminine trying to navigate the fresh contradictive femininity.
Intriguingly, in many manga, cartoon, and you can video game, menhera girls is actually first delivered given that lovable, loveable, and you will nurturing on their like hobbies
Paradoxically, the hyperlink anywhere between menhera and you can stereotypical femininity provides contributed to menhera’s sudden escalation in popularity, including contained in this manga/cartoon centering on men audience. Eg, Last Menhera (Amano and you will Ise, 2016) is actually a beneficial seinen manga (more youthful male comical) you to definitely uses a high-school boy dropping in love with a good beautiful classmate just who thinking-slices (Contour dos). Throughout the story, the new heroine engages in repeating arm slashing so you can “endure the pain sensation out of life” and you may “delay brand new , p. 56) leading other emails to help you term their unique menhera. The male protagonist pretends which he, also, self-injures to attract her attention and you may love. From protagonist’s male look, brand new heroine’s marked human body will get the item out of affective practices whereby self-injury signifies their susceptability, helplessness, and deformity, and therefore completely comprises a kinky sexual desire (Seko and you can Kikuchi, 2020).
The latest Crazy Woman
Whereas, new sad girl story domesticates female insanity because the vulnerable and you will potentially erotic, the fresh upset lady exaggerates their abnormality and you may derangement, especially in the brand new perspective regarding personal matchmaking. Within this story, this new menhera is obsessed with their own love attract and renders devastating work is with this people. But not, when a third people goes into the new equation, their low self-esteem exhibits given that possessive advice and strategies, overprotectiveness, and you will extreme envy that appears peculiar and you can terrifying to someone else (Kato, 2018). In the place of the brand new sad girls whom walking good tightrope within typical therefore the disordered, the new frustrated woman firmly inhabits the realm of insanity.
Comments
